Kahneman Himself Clarifies Thinking Systems 1 and 2 - Security Boulevard

SBN Kahneman Himself Clarifies Thinking Systems 1 and 2

Sometimes I am asked to review or explain the Kahneman framework of thinking systems he wrote a book about.

I suppose this comes up most when I describe the same things in many of my presentations, such as my last one given at RSAC:

DevOps Experience
RSAC SF 2020 Presentation on AI

My point usually has been that veterinarian science used this duality in thinking to solve Rinderpest (as I wrote here in 2010, a year before Kahneman’s very famous best-selling book was published).

And my point in describing the dual-system that solved Rinderpest, for such a huge accomplishment as ending a disease, has been that our security community maybe could do similar things to solve for integrity attacks on information systems. You say we have a problem with disinformation campaigns and I’ll say I have a possible solution!

Kahneman himself just gave a brief three minute presentation the other day in an “AI Debate”. He quickly starts off by admitting “they’re not my idea but i wrote a book to describe them”.

He then goes on to say his understanding of system one is that “things happen to you, you don’t do them”, calling them automatic and parallelized, whereas system two is “something you do” and serialized… all of which seems very consistent with my slides.

They system split is not my idea either, as I’ve always said, but I am also writing a book to describe them.

What is most interesting in his presentation is while he tells us that system one is “our world” it’s probably more accurate to say (by his own admission) that in system one we are seeing shadows on Plato’s cave wall, not the strings we pull.

*** This is a Security Bloggers Network syndicated blog from flyingpenguin authored by Davi Ottenheimer. Read the original post at: https://www.flyingpenguin.com/?p=30738

Techstrong Group